agasfer (agasfer) wrote,

Типичный махровый идеализм

Although these are outdated explanations -- the left and the right argue about other things these days -- they still have an impact. Recently Gore Vidal described the Cold War as "40 years of mindless wars which created a debt of $5 trillion." Is that what it was -- or was it a sometimes ill-fought, sometimes wasteful, sometimes embarrassing but nevertheless necessary battle against a totalitarian regime that murdered millions of people? Not long ago, a British journalist, writing in a conservative magazine, described the Cold War as "the most unnecessary conflict of all time." Is that the case -- or did our frequently clumsy interventions around the world prevent the Stalinist system from spreading, at least to a few places?

The answers to these questions matter at a time when the West is once again fighting an ideological enemy, in the form of radical Islam. If we remembered, truly remembered, why the Cold War was fought and how it was won, for example, we would know that it is unacceptable to alter our liberal democracy in order to fight the war on terrorism either at home or abroad. This week, I heard a university professor tell a television interviewer that he thought the use of torture in the interrogation of Khalid Sheik Mohammed, the al Qaeda leader, was acceptable, as long as it is done abroad, and as long as it is not used on U.S. citizens. Elsewhere, Sen. Jay Rockefeller said, "We don't sanction torture," but there are "psychological and other ways we can get what we need" out of him -- whatever that means. Comments such as these have sparked, once again, a mini-storm about whether Americans should be allowed to use torture or not.

Properly understood, the history of the Cold War should lead us directly to the answer: We fought Stalin's system because it was inhuman, not just because it was powerful. Our weapons helped us to win, but our victory, in the end, had far more to do with the moral and material success of Western society and the bankruptcy of communism. On the anniversary of Stalin's death, it is worth remembering that radical Islam will also come to a swifter end if we abide by our own rules of decency at home, and apply them to others as well.
(. . . A Lesson For the West/By Anne Applebaum Washington Post, Wednesday, March 5, 2003; Page A21)

  • Подводное

    Про акул вам уже надоело, поди? Так что будем сворачивать тему. Это Эмма, самая большая из увиденных на Тигровом Берегу акул: Ее легко узнать по…

  • Из Цыкла "ЛДП Рядом с Нами"

    В Гонолулу 10-летняя девочка была арестована за рисунок, огорчивший кого-то из родителей Я бы здесь не акцентировал на том, что девочка черная.…

  • Пишут и Говорят, Что...

    ...шансы черепашьего яйца стать взрослой морской черепахой оцениваются примерно, как 1 из 7 тыс... ...в марсианском небе на роль Полярной звезды…

  • Post a new comment


    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded